The Autel X Star and DJI Phantom 4 were two leading camera drones in their prime. While neither is in production today, understanding their differences can provide valuable context for today’s drone market. This comparison delves into the key features of each drone, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses to help you appreciate their place in drone history.
Camera Capabilities: A Close Contest
Both the Autel X Star Premium and the DJI Phantom 4 boasted impressive camera capabilities for their time. The X Star Premium featured a 4K Ultra HD camera capable of capturing stunning video footage and 12-megapixel still photos. Its 108-degree field of view offered a wide perspective, and the integrated 3-axis gimbal ensured smooth, stable shots. Similarly, the Phantom 4 offered 4K video recording and 12-megapixel photos. While specific image quality comparisons would depend on individual testing and conditions, both drones represented a significant leap forward in aerial photography.
Flight Performance and Features
Both drones offered various intelligent flight modes, including Follow Me, Orbit, and Waypoint navigation. Autel’s “beginner mode” included a geo-fence to limit flight range and speed for novice pilots. While both drones had a top speed of around 16 m/s, anecdotal reports suggested the Autel X Star felt more agile and responsive in flight, although potentially less stable for smooth takeoffs and landings.
Design and Build: Key Differences Emerge
A key differentiator between the two drones was the X Star’s removable gimbal and camera. This modular design offered potential advantages for future upgrades and customization. Users could potentially swap out cameras or utilize the gimbal mount for other accessories. The Phantom 4, with its fixed camera, lacked this flexibility. Furthermore, the X Star was noticeably bright orange, a distinct contrast to the Phantom’s more subdued white design.
Controller and App Experience
Both drones utilized a smartphone app and dedicated remote controller for flight control and first-person-view (FPV) video feed. The Autel X Star’s controller boasted dedicated buttons for functions like return-to-home and takeoff, potentially simplifying operation for beginners. Both required their respective apps – Starlink for Autel and DJI GO for the Phantom.
Price and Value Proposition
At the time of its release, the Autel X Star was priced slightly higher than the Phantom 3 Advanced, but comparably to the Phantom 4. The X Star’s removable gimbal offered a potential long-term cost saving by allowing for component upgrades instead of replacing the entire drone. This modularity, along with its included hard case and accessories, presented a strong value proposition for users seeking flexibility and potential future-proofing.
Conclusion: A Strong Competitor to the Phantom
The Autel X Star emerged as a compelling alternative to the dominant DJI Phantom 4. Its agile flight characteristics, removable gimbal system, and user-friendly features made it a strong contender in the consumer drone market. While the Phantom series ultimately prevailed in market share, the Autel X Star showcased innovative design elements and a focus on consumer needs that pushed the industry forward. It remains a noteworthy example of a drone that successfully challenged the established leader and offered a compelling alternative for aerial photography enthusiasts.
